Review: THE SITTAFORD MYSTERY, Agatha Christie

• 
  This edition read on my tablet as a free downloadable pdf 
• Originally published 1931
  
• ASIN ‏ : ‎ B0046REG94
• this edition Publisher ‏ : ‎ HarperCollins (October 14, 2010)
• Print length ‏ : ‎ 289 pages
• AKA THE MURDER AT HAZELMOOR (title for USA publication)
• My original review (2009)  and then another in 2022

Synopsis 

A seance in a snowbound Dartmoor house predicts a grisly murder…

In a remote house in the middle of Dartmoor, six shadowy figures huddle around a small table for a seance. Tension rises as the spirits spell out a chilling message: ‘Captain Trevelyan… dead… murder.’

Is this black magic or simply a macabre joke? The only way to be certain is to locate Captain Trevelyan. Unfortunately, his home is six miles away and, with snow drifts blocking the roads, someone will have to make the journey on foot… 

My Take

I am re-reading this novel with my U3A Agatha Christie Reading Group and look forward to discussing it with them. I think it works quite well as a stand-alone mystery that has some romantic elements thrown in.

So here are some of the elements in the novel we will discuss

• The role of the seance as the harbinger of death. How did that work? Who was it that told the gathering that the message was for Major Burnaby?
• What are the relationships between the various characters? (How did they keep track of the characters? There are a lot of them)
• Why have Miss Willett and Mrs Willett really taken Captain Trevelyan's house?
• What is the role of Emily Trefusis in solving the murder?
• How effective is Inspector Narracott and what is the role of Mr Duke?
• Who are the most memorable characters? What makes them so?
  
• Which are the most effective red herrings?
• This novel is a stand-alone, although I think at this stage Agatha Christie was still looking for a suitable sleuth. Will Inspector Narracott appear in future novels do you think?
• What does the isolation of Sittaford House make you think of? What about the escaped convict scenario?
• How credible is the secondary plot (the Willett scenario)
• What did you think of Charles Enderby? How good is he as a journalist?
• Why did the murderer commit the murder? Is the reason given plausible?
• Why did ITV decide to turn it into a Marple rather than leave it as a stand-alone. How does changing the plot for television make it more attractive? 

We usually watch a television version of it after our discussion but of course the ITV version is a Miss Marple, with a very much altered plot. I have put that at the bottom of this page in case you don't want to know the details. I am not sure whether the group will want to watch this as it is so dissimilar to the original.

One of the things we are finding as a reading group is how difficult it is to borrow an Agatha Christie novel (a printed book rather than an e-copy). 

My rating: 4.5

All my Agatha Christie Reviews. 

The Television version

The Sittaford Mystery is the fourth episode of the second series of Agatha Christie's Marple. It was broadcast on ITV by Granada Television on 30 April 2006. The screenplay was written by Stephen Churchett and the episode was directed by Paul Unwin. It was an adaptation of the Agatha Christie novel of the same name although originally Miss Marple was not involved. 

Synopsis

When Clive Trevelyan - Member of Parliament, war hero and heir apparent to Prime Minister Winston Churchill - is killed, Miss Marple sets about to solve the case. Trevelyan has made his fortune many years before in Egypt having secretly uncovered a lost tomb. He is killed during a major snowstorm when there are no police available. There are several possible suspects including Trevelyan's ward, James Pearson and his fiancée Emily Trefusis; his political agent, John Enderby; a journalist Charles Burnaby; a visiting American Martin Zimmerman; and several other apparently disinterested parties. A convict has also escaped from Dartmoor prison. Miss Marple concludes that Trevelyan's murder is related to his days in Egypt and sets about to identify the murderer. 

Comparison with the original story

The Sittaford Mystery was not originally a Miss Marple book. Some plot elements from the original are retained but spun together differently to result in a totally new story. Most of the characters are new and even the few who have some part of the original names now have totally different backstories.

•     The identity of the killer is not the same as in the novel.
•     Several characters have different names than in the novel.
•     Several characters are omitted or changed.

Review: VALUED FOR MURDER, Victoria Tait

• 
  Read as an e-book on my Kindle (Amazon)
  
• ASIN ‏ : ‎ B09TRXWWNG
• Publisher ‏ : ‎ Kanga Press, Publication date ‏ : ‎ 10 June 2022
• Print length ‏ : ‎ 194 pages
• ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-1915413000
• Book 2 of 12 ‏ : ‎ A Dotty Sayers Antique Mystery  

Synopsis (Amazon)

An antique TV show. A dead celebrity expert. Can a shy amateur sleuth step into the lime-light and expose a murderer?

Dotty Sayers is enjoying her job in a Cotswold auction house. When she’s offered a place on an antique TV show, she nervously agrees to a makeover and is surprised by the admiring glances she receives. But working at a historic country hotel, she realises the production is in jeopardy when, at the bottom of the circular staircase, one of the experts is found dead.

Dotty can’t help wondering if the death was accidental or if someone else was involved. She promises to stay in the background and leave the investigation to the police, but this amateur detective can’t help uncovering clues. When she returns from viewing a priceless sculpture, and finds her British blue cat missing, she knows she’ll struggle to keep the show on the road.

Can Dotty emerge from behind the scenes and identify the killer?

Valued for Murder is a British cozy mystery featuring a shy but determined amateur sleuth, a behind‑the‑scenes antique TV show, a suspicious “accidental” death in a country‑house hotel, and a missing beloved cat. It blends small‑village charm, light humour, and a slow‑burn personal journey as Dotty steps out of the shadows, navigates prickly TV personalities and nosy locals, and pieces together clues the professionals overlook. Perfect for readers who enjoy closed-circle whodunits, gentle peril rather than gore, and character‑driven mysteries set against quintessentially English, Cotswold scenery.

My Take

As you can see, I have persisted with this series and I have found this outing marginally better that the previous one FAKE DEATH. Dotty is showing potential and is a stronger character. The plot has a couple of nice elements.

So I will be reading more. 

My rating: 4.4

I've also read

4.3, FAKE DEATH - #1

Review: FAKE DEATH, Victoria Tait

• 
  This edition read on my Kindle (Amazon)
  
• ASIN ‏ : ‎ B09TLDS3G1
• Publisher ‏ : ‎ Kanga Press, Publication date ‏ : ‎ 8 April 2022
• Print length ‏ : ‎ 198 pages
• ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-1838436100
• Book 1 of 12 ‏ : ‎ A Dotty Sayers Antique Mystery 

Synopsis  (Amazon)

One dead body. Multiple identities. Can an amateur sleuth see through the charade before she becomes the next victim?

Young widow Dotty Sayers is delighted with her new auction house job in Britain’s picturesque Cotswolds, until she discovers she’s about to lose her home and her chance at a fresh start. Disguising her disappointment, she reluctantly takes part in an autumn parade, but the day’s pageantry is tarnished when an unknown man is found dead.

The police ask Dotty to appraise items from the victim’s home, but rather than learning his name, she uncovers a trail of false identities. When one of them leads to a client, her search for the truth takes a fatal turn.

Can Dotty unmask the killer before she becomes the next victim?

Fake Death is the first book in the Dotty Sayers Antique Mystery series, a British cozy set in the Cotswolds among an auction house and close-knit village community. Featuring a young military widow turned amateur sleuth who is still finding her feet and building a found family, it delivers a clue driven mystery with multiple identities and no graphic content, perfect for readers who enjoy traditional whodunnits, antiques, and small town secrets with a modern, character focused touch. 

My Take

This novel has all the hallmarks of the beginning of the series - a lot of characters, heaps of information to absorb. For me, the name of the main character took a bit of getting over (see my note elsewhere about coat-tails) and I also found her a bit "soft" as a character. Straightening out who is who and who does what in the antiques firm that Dotty has joined was a challenge. So in reality it is a series that you really need to read from the beginning, one where accumulated knowledge will be an advantage.

The setting seems rather loosely based on those television shows we all watch like Antiques Road Show and Bargain Hunt. The extra element of a crime or two happening in this setting has potential but to be honest Dotty is going to have to get stronger to be a satisfactory sleuth.

In addition a number of the other characters seem to have extensive background stories attached to them, only partially revealed, and at times I had the feeling of having come in in mid-conversation. 

My rating: 4.3

About the author - website

Victoria Tait was born and raised in Yorkshire, England, where she developed a lifelong love of tea and British traditions. Inspired by the works of Agatha Christie, Dorothy L. Sayers, and Murder, She Wrote, she writes cozy mysteries infused with her signature British charm.

Her determined and hard-working female sleuths are joined by colourful but realistic teams of helpers, and her settings are vivid and evocative. With intrigue, surprises, and gentle humour, Victoria’s page-turning stories are the perfect blend of mystery and charm—best enjoyed with a cup of tea and a slice of cake. 

Review: THE HOUSEMAID, Freida McFadden

• 
  this edition from my local library
  
• paperback edition published 2023 by Bookouture  
• ISBN 987-1-4087-2851-2
• 328 pages 

Synopsis (publisher) 

“Welcome to the family,” Nina Winchester says as I shake her elegant, manicured hand. I smile politely, gazing around the marble hallway. Working here is my last chance to start fresh. I can pretend to be whoever I like. But I’ll soon learn that the Winchesters’ secrets are far more dangerous than my own…

Every day I clean the Winchesters’ beautiful house top to bottom. I collect their daughter from school. And I cook a delicious meal for the whole family before heading up to eat alone in my tiny room on the top floor.

I try to ignore how Nina makes a mess just to watch me clean it up. How she tells strange lies about her own daughter. And how her husband Andrew seems more broken every day. But as I look into Andrew’s handsome brown eyes, so full of pain, it’s hard not to imagine what it would be like to live Nina’s life. The walk-in closet, the fancy car, the perfect husband.

I only try on one of Nina’s pristine white dresses once. Just to see what it’s like. But she soon finds out… and by the time I realize my attic bedroom door only locks from the outside, it’s far too late.

But I reassure myself: the Winchesters don’t know who I really am.

They don’t know what I’m capable of…

My Take

Another excellent twisty tale. You just get used to the direction this book is taking, and think you have it all figured out, and it goes around another corner. And I don't think anything prepares you for the way it ends. 

My rating: 4.6

I've also read

4.5, THE TENANT

4.5, DO NOT DISTURB 

4.5, WANT TO KNOW A SECRET?

4.7, DEAR DEBBIE 

Review: REYKJAVIK, Ragnar Jonasson & Katrin Jakobsdottir

• 
  this edition a paperback published by Penguin Random House UK 2023
  
• first published in Icelandic 2022
• translated into English by Victoria Cribb
• made available by my local library 
• ISBN 978-0-241-62600-9
• 371 pages 

Synopsis (publisher)

An ice-cold mystery haunts Reykjavík in 1986, in this heart-stopping new crime novel co-written by the Icelandic Prime Minister Katrín Jakobsdottir

What happened to Lara?

Iceland, 1956. Fourteen-year-old Lara spends the summer on the small island of Videy, just off the coast of Reykjavík.

In early August, the girl disappears without a trace.

The mystery becomes Iceland's greatest unsolved case. What happened to the young girl? Is she still alive? Did she leave the island, or did something happen to her there?

Thirty years later, journalist Valur Robertsson begins his own investigation into Lara's case. But as he draws closer to discovering the secret, it's soon clear that this is a mystery someone will stop at nothing to keep unsolved...

My Take

The book is dedicated to Agatha Christie, and certainly there are some Christie-like effects to the plot. The story takes place over 30 years, from the mysterious disappearance of 14 year old Lara to the climax of the story in 1986, the year of the celebration of Iceland's 200th Anniversary.

I thought the Icelandic climate played a less-than-usual role in the story. There were plenty of red herrings and the eventual revelation of the murderer came as a real surprise in true Christie fashion.  

My rating: 4.7

I've also read (by Ragnar Jonasson)

4.4, THE MIST

4.5, WHITE OUT 

4.5, WINTERKILL 

4.6, THE MIST

4.6, RUPTURE 

4.7, THE DARKNESS 

Review: THE WOMAN IN SUITE 11, Ruth Ware

• 
  This edition an e-book read on my Kindle (AmazonAU)
  
• ASIN ‏ : ‎ B0DJMGTT6R
• Publisher ‏ : ‎ Simon & Schuster UK, Publication date ‏ : ‎ 17 July 2025
• Print length ‏ : ‎ 400 pages
• ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-1398526754
• Book 2 of 2 ‏ : ‎ Lo Blacklock  

Synopsis (AmazonAU)

Paradise comes at a price . . .

The stunning mountain views. The beautiful shore of Lake Geneva. The terrified woman held in the suite belonging to the hotel’s millionaire owner.

Lo Blacklock’s all-expenses paid trip to a luxury Swiss chateau should have been the ideal return to work. But as her past catches up with her, the millionaire’s mistress demanding that Lo help her escape, and a body turning up in the room next door, forces Lo to ask how far would she go to help someone she’s not even sure she can trust… 

My Take

This story is the sequel to 4.4, THE WOMAN IN CABIN 10 which was published nearly 10 years ago. In fact 10 years has elapsed in "real time" since the events that took place in that story. 

The offer of an all-expenses-paid jaunt to Switzerland has come at just the right time for Laura Blacklock who is more than ready to re-start her career as a travel journalist. In the last ten years she has married, written a book about what happened on the Aurora ten years ago, had two children, and become an American citizen living in New York.

Laura is astounded to find that 3 other people from the Aurora incident have also been invited to the conference in Geneva, which is the launch of a new style of tourism by a very wealthy family firm. And then she discovers that the person behind the invitation is none other than Carrie from the Aurora ten years before. Laura discovers that Carrie has plans of her own.

There is an interesting section in the author's notes at the end of the book about writing a sequel to the earlier book.

It is nearly 10 years since I have read THE WOMAN IN CABIN 10, and my memories of what happened were a bit fragmentary, always a bit of a problem in reading a sequel. 

My rating: 4.6

I've also read

4.8, IN A DARK, DARK WOOD

4.4, THE WOMAN IN CABIN 10

4.8, THE DEATH OF MRS WESTAWAY

5.0, THE TURN OF THE KEY

4.6, THE IT GIRL

4.8, ZERO DAYS

4.8, ONE BY ONE 

4.7, ONE PERFECT COUPLE 

 

Review: DEAR DEBBIE, Freida McFadden

• 
  This edition a paperback supplied by my local library
  
• Published 2026 by Sourcebooks, Poisoned Pen Press
• isbn-13: 978-1-4642-6649-2
• 327 pages   

 Synopsis (publisher)

Sometimes, enough is enough…

Debbie Mullen is losing it. For years, she has compiled all of her best advice into her column, Dear Debbie, where the wives of New England come for sympathy and neighborly advice. Through her work, Debbie has heard from countless women who are ignored, belittled, or even abused by their husbands. And Debbie does her best to guide them in the right direction. 

Or at least, she did. 

These days, Debbie’s life seems to be spiraling out of control. She just lost her job. Something strange is happening with her teenage daughters. And her husband is keeping secrets, according to the tracking app she installed on his phone. Now, Debbie’s done being the bigger person. She’s done being reasonable and practical. It’s time to take her own advice. 

And now it’s time for payback against all the people in her life who deserve it the most.

My Take

I am really hooked on this author. All the stories by her that I have read have been instantly engaging, and all have had a twist in the tail, usually in a direction you are not expecting. In this one, the principal character, Debbie, gets away with murder, but you do have to ask yourself if her victims didn't deserve what happened.  

My Rating: 4.7

I've also read

4.5, THE TENANT

4.5, DO NOT DISTURB 

4.5, WANT TO KNOW A SECRET?